I have an anomalous trichromacy color vision deficiency (I’m green-red color blind). That doesn’t mean I can’t ever see the difference between green and red, but it does mean that I have trouble telling the difference between certain pairs of colors when they’re of similar tone and saturation. Examples of such pairs would be:
- Yellow/Green
- Green/Red
- Blue/Purple
- Green/Brown
- Red/Brown
- Orange/Yellow
When they’re of different enough tone and saturation, I can tell them apart. For example, I’d never confuse dark orange and light yellow. (Many thanks to kfredericks who’s color examples I stole.)
In every day life, this “disorder” doesn’t really effect me much. I’m terrible at matching clothes, but that can be mostly avoided by wearing blue-jeans and khakis, and letting my wife pick out my daughter’s outfits at the store and at home. I do have trouble with traffic lights regularly, but green is usually on the bottom or the left (or is it right….I guess it can be a problem sometimes).
But when it comes to playing casual video games, a color vision deficiency can be a real pain. I say “casual” because this isn’t much of a problem in action based games like Half-Life or Bioshock. There are puzzles in these types of games, but they don’t usually involve colors. Every now and then an adventure game (think Myst) will throw color puzzles at me, but I always play those with my wife, so she bails us out nicely.
No, it’s casual games that always get me with colors. One of my favorites is Zuma (I even have it on my mobile phone), and it unfortunately starts with yellow and green in it’s color mix, and a few levels later adds a purple that looks just like blue to me. They could have made these colors have different tones and saturations and I would have been ok, or even gone a step further with different patterns (the balls do have different faces, but they can be hard to see since they’re rolling, and special power-up balls lose their pattern and have to be matched by color alone) for people with even worse color deficiencies, but they didn’t. I still play the game, but I often goof up the colors, especially on my little phone screen, and have to “die” in frustration,
I had kind of given up on every expecting games like these to have support for color blind people. But then I had a chance to play Peggle (came free as part of Half Life 2: Episode Two), made by PopCap Games (the same company that made Zuma), and it has a Colorblind Mode that adds a triangle to the green pegs and a plus to the purple pegs to make them easier to distinguish.
Come on PopCap, keep it up! Don’t stop at adding colorblind support to new games (although way to go for setting a new standard for other companies to follow). Go back and fix some of your older, but just as popular games like Zuma.
Roughly 5% of the male population is colorblind, so the problem isn’t a microscopic one. Throw in some patterns and help us out!
Peggle is awesome! The best part is when you hit the last ball and “Ode to Joy” blasts through your speakers. It’s so elating!
I got the free download at Popcap.com and played it all the time for a while. I can’t get past certain levels in it because I’m unwilling to pay for it, but it’s a good one. Zuma is sweet, too.
I never thought about how colorblindness would affect playing games, but clearly it does. I echo your call for more patterns in the games.
Oh man, the “Ode to Joy” part is almost my whole reason for playing! Does the free version let you get to the level “The Dude Abides”? I thought I remember you being a Lebowski fan. Anyway, the background is bowling pins.
Ok, I just read this on Wikipedia:
And YouTube proves it!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jk2KQ6MzqBw
There’s a Lebowski level? Oh man, that would be fun! I haven’t seen that one in quite a while.
Hi, I’m R/G colorblind, and I love Zuma! It really pisses me off when i mix the colors, so one day I decided to change the colors of the balls. You can do it too, you just need PaintNet (free, and you have color wheel so you wont get confused). All PopCap games can be easily edited, because there is images folder with all GUI items inside (DON’T TOUCH Black and White Images unless you’re changing the shape). I changed the purple color to black, and darkened the green. Voila! No troubles now! Try it your self, but if you get stuck, I’ll be glad to help you – wlado.srbija@gmail.com đŸ™‚